Understanding Withholding of Removal and the Convention Against Torture (CAT) Protections

For individuals facing deportation, Withholding of Removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT) provide critical forms of relief. These legal protections prevent removal to a country where an individual is likely to face persecution, torture, or life-threatening harm. While different from asylum, these options serve as essential safeguards for those who do not qualify for asylum but still need protection.

What Is Withholding of Removal?

Withholding of Removal is a legal protection under Section 241(b)(3) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) that prohibits the U.S. government from deporting an individual to a country where their life or freedom would be threatened based on:

✔ Race
✔ Religion
✔ Nationality
✔ Membership in a particular social group
✔ Political opinion

Unlike asylum, which grants a path to permanent residency, Withholding of Removal does not provide a green card or allow petitioning for family members. However, it does allow individuals to live and work legally in the U.S. as long as the risk in their home country persists.

Eligibility Criteria for Withholding of Removal

To qualify, an applicant must demonstrate that:

They face a “clear probability” of persecution in their home country (i.e., there is more than a 50% likelihood of harm).
The persecution is based on a protected ground (race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group).
They are not barred from protection due to past criminal offenses, terrorist activities, or other disqualifying factors.

What Is Protection Under the Convention Against Torture (CAT)?

The Convention Against Torture (CAT) is an international treaty that prohibits the deportation of individuals to countries where they will likely be subjected to torture. Unlike Withholding of Removal, CAT protections apply regardless of the reason for torture—it does not require proof of persecution based on race, religion, or political opinion.

Eligibility Criteria for CAT Protection

To be eligible for protection under CAT, an applicant must prove that:

✅ They will more likely than not face torture if removed to their home country.
✅ The torture is inflicted by the government or a group that the government cannot or will not control.
✅ The harm meets the legal definition of torture—severe physical or mental suffering intentionally inflicted for punishment, intimidation, or coercion.

Types of Protection Under CAT

CAT relief is granted in two ways:

Withholding of Removal under CAT – Prevents deportation to the country where the applicant would be tortured. However, the applicant can still be removed to a third country if one is available.
Deferral of Removal under CAT – A temporary form of protection for individuals who are ineligible for asylum or withholding (due to criminal convictions, security risks, etc.). This does not grant permanent residency or work authorization, and it can be revoked if conditions change.

Key Differences: Asylum vs. Withholding vs. CAT Protection

Factor	Asylum	Withholding of Removal	Convention Against Torture (CAT)
Basis for Protection	Fear of persecution on protected grounds	Fear of persecution on protected grounds	Fear of torture (no requirement for protected grounds)
Burden of Proof	“Well-founded fear” (reasonable possibility)	“More likely than not” (51% probability)	“More likely than not” (51% probability)
Legal Status Given	Permanent residence (green card after 1 year)	Indefinite stay in the U.S. but no green card	No green card, only temporary protection
Ability to Apply for Family	Yes, can petition for family members	No, cannot petition for family	No, cannot petition for family
Work Authorization	Yes	Yes	Limited, depends on status
Can Be Sent to a Third Country?	No	Yes	Yes

Common Challenges in Withholding of Removal and CAT Cases

Obtaining relief under Withholding of Removal or CAT is legally complex and requires strong evidence. Common challenges include:

High Burden of Proof – Applicants must prove they are more likely than not to face persecution or torture, which is a higher standard than asylum.
Criminal Inadmissibility – Certain crimes may bar eligibility for Withholding of Removal, though CAT protections may still apply.
Government Involvement in Harm – For CAT protection, applicants must show that torture is state-sanctioned or condoned.
No Path to Citizenship – Unlike asylum, neither Withholding of Removal nor CAT leads to a green card or U.S. citizenship.

Given the complexity of these protections, having an experienced immigration attorney significantly increases the chances of success.

How BPR Immigration Law Can Help

BPR Immigration Law provides expert guidance for individuals seeking Withholding of Removal and CAT protection. Our services include:

✔ Case Evaluation – Assessing eligibility for relief options.
✔ Evidence Gathering – Documenting threats, country conditions, and persecution claims.
✔ Legal Representation – Advocating in immigration court and appeals.
✔ Filing for Alternative Relief – Exploring asylum, humanitarian visas, or other forms of protection.

Understanding Withholding of Removal and CAT relief is essential for individuals facing deportation. While these protections do not lead to a green card, they offer a crucial safeguard against life-threatening harm. Seeking professional legal guidance can make all the difference in securing a favorable outcome.

Why Partner with Benach, Pitney, & Reilly Immigration

Personalized Strategy: Each case receives a tailored approach based on specific circumstances.
Proven Track Record: Success in uniting families through immigration solutions.
Clear Communication: Regular updates and transparency throughout the legal process.
Dedicated Advocacy: Persistent efforts to achieve favorable case outcomes.

Would you like any adjustments based on specific priorities (e.g., more emphasis on criminal bars, work authorization, etc.)?

See What Our Clients Say About Us!

""I am beyond grateful for the incredible support I received from my immigration lawyer, Ava Benach, and her amazing team. From the very start, they treated me with kindness, patience, and understanding, making a complex and overwhelming process feel manageable. Despite the challenges of my case, Ava made the impossible possible. She is not only an exceptional attorney but also a compassionate and generous human being who genuinely cares about her clients. Her dedication, expertise, and unwavering support were invaluable to me. I also want to extend my deepest gratitude to Ava’s wonderful colleagues, Ashley and Erica, who were incredibly helpful, meticulous, and always punctual. Their attention to detail and commitment made all the difference, and I truly appreciate their hard work. The level of service I received was worth far more than the fees we paid. Ava’s knowledge and professionalism are unmatched, and I trusted her completely every step of the way. If you need an immigration lawyer who will fight for you while treating you with respect and care, I wholeheartedly recommend Ava Benach and her team. Thank you, Ava, Ashley, Erica, and the entire team, for everything you have done for me!"" - Abdullah K.

""For those of you who need immigration assistance from a kind human soul and an expert lawyer, you don’t need to look further than Ava Benach. I have known Ava since around 2013, and throughout the years, she has been more than just my lawyer—she has been a trusted advocate, a source of strength, and a guiding light during uncertain times. From the very first moment I spoke with her, I felt an immediate sense of trust and reassurance. She listens with genuine care, treats every case with the utmost dedication, and makes sure her clients fully understand their options. Ava’s expertise in immigration law is unmatched. She has an incredible ability to break down even the most complex legal matters, ensuring her clients feel informed and empowered. She is not just a brilliant attorney—she is also a compassionate human being who truly cares about the people she represents. Beyond her legal work, Ava’s dedication to helping others extends to her writing and advocacy. Her blog on naturalized citizenship and denaturalization is just one example of how she takes the time to educate and support not only her clients but also the wider immigrant community. She goes above and beyond to make sure people have the knowledge and resources they need to navigate their journey with confidence. I cannot fully express how grateful I am to have had Ava by my side. She is an exceptional attorney who fights tirelessly for justice while treating her clients with kindness, respect, and unwavering support. If you need an immigration lawyer who is not only highly skilled but also deeply compassionate, Ava Benach is the one to call. Thank you, Ava, for everything you have done for me and for so many others. You are truly making a difference in the world, and I am forever grateful."" - Genet A.

""I am incredibly grateful to Benach Pitney Reilly Immigration for their outstanding support and expertise throughout my immigration case. From the very first consultation, I felt welcomed and assured that I was in good hands. The team was not only knowledgeable but also genuinely caring, taking the time to answer all my questions and explain the process in detail. Ava and Sarah were especially helpful, and they guided me every step of the way, providing clear communication and keeping me updated on progress. Their hard work and dedication made a significant difference in experience. I highly recommend Benach Pitney Reilly Immigration to anyone in need of immigration assistance. They are truly a team of professionals who care about their clients and fight for their success. Thank you once again, Benach Pitney Reilly Immigration !"" - Raymond A.

""I cannot express enough gratitude to Benach Pitney Reilly Immigration. Thanks to your professionalism, dedication, and deep knowledge of immigration law, I now have my green card. From day one, your team demonstrated a genuine commitment to my case, providing not only expert advice but also compassionate support that made all the difference in this important process for me. I wholeheartedly recommend Benach Pitney Reilly Immigration to anyone looking for a reliable, professional and efficient team for immigration matters and thank you. miss sarah pitney for helping me in this long process that gave everything so that i was in the best way thank you for everything"" - Carlos M.

""I cannot express enough gratitude to Benach Collopy LLP. Thanks to their professionalism, dedication, and deep knowledge of immigration law, I now have my green card. From day one, their team demonstrated genuine commitment to my case, providing not only expert advice but also compassionate support that made all the difference in this important process for me. I wholeheartedly recommend Benach Collopy LLP to anyone seeking a reliable, professional, and efficient team for immigration matters. Thank you for changing my life!"" - Alessia O.

""Ava is an immigration powerhouse! Her expertise and commitment to her clients are unmatched. While other lawyers were at a loss, Ava took charge and confidently navigated our case with precision. From day one, she knew exactly what needed to be done and executed it flawlessly. Thanks to Ava’s relentless dedication, we have our green card! She went above and beyond, and we are beyond grateful for her exceptional work. If you need an immigration expert, Ava is the one you want on your side."" - Fede P.

""My Immigration Journey: From Uncertainty to Triumph! I embarked on my immigration journey 5-6 years ago, navigating uncharted waters with little understanding of the complex process. I faced numerous challenges, changed lawyers, and sought answers, but to no avail. That was until I found Benach Pitney Reilly Immigration. Through diligent research, I discovered the right team and was fortunate to have Dree as my initial consultation attorney. She was knowledgeable, empathetic, and provided invaluable guidance, setting the tone for a successful partnership. As my case progressed, I had the pleasure of working with David, who took the reins and expertly navigated me through the remaining process. David, you are a beacon of hope, guidance, and humility. Your selflessness, compassion, and willingness to help are traits that make you an outstanding attorney and an inspiration to many. Under the exceptional guidance of Dree and David, my immigration process transformed from a daunting task to a manageable and successful journey. The entire team's professionalism, empathy, and commitment to excellence are unparalleled. To anyone seeking immigration guidance, I highly recommend Benach Pitney Reilly Immigration. Sofia , David, and the team are the epitome of excellence, and I'm honored to have had the privilege of working with them. Thank you, David and Sofia for being shining examples of what it means to serve with humility and kindness."" - Shoukat A.

Contact us today

Take the Next Step – Schedule a Consultation

Providing Immigration Services Nationwide & Locally in Washington, D.C.

Immigration matters require informed decisions and timely action. Professional legal guidance ensures a smooth and efficient process. Secure an opportunity to discuss case-specific needs and explore the best path forward.

202-644-8600